Dark gray tiled roof with skylights, dormer windows, and a matching chimney beneath a partly cloudy sky.

Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles: What’s the Difference?

Which is a better choice for your home: an asphalt or metal roof? In this blog, you’ll learn the differences between asphalt and metal roofs so you can make an informed selection.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs with exposed fasteners are manufactured using the most common metal roofing materials, such as sheet steel and aluminum. Commercial applications frequently utilize concealed fastenings known as standing seam. Standing seam is superior in terms of appearance and durability and as such, costlier than the other style.

A metal roof comprises a fortified water barrier substrate and then a layer of metal strips, which are fastened with small clips. These clips, or fasteners, can allow the metal components of the roof to shift more freely, ensuring the metal can expand and contract with long exposure to sunlight while preventing any damage to the fasteners or the roof itself.

Free Quote

Ask About Financing

Two-story gray Craftsman-style home with white trim, illuminated windows, a covered front porch, and landscaped lawn at dusk.

Cold drafts around your windows, a front door that leaks air, and rising utility bills can make winters in Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, and Central New Jersey feel even harsher...

Large gray Craftsman-style home with white trim, dormer windows, a covered front porch, and a landscaped lawn.

Cold winters in New York and New Jersey can take a serious toll on your home’s exterior...

Four white-framed casement windows overlooking snow-covered trees and a winter landscape.

Replacing your windows is a smart investment, but many New Jersey homeowners hesitate because they’re unsure what the process involves...

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles have a fiberglass core which is then layered with asphalt and finally ceramic granules. These shingles deliver a more affordable roofing option for homeowners, while securing a home robust protection against the elements from anywhere between 15 to 30 years. There are two primary kinds of asphalt shingles: three-tab which are less expensive, single layer shingles, as well as architectural shingles. Three-tab shingles are manufactured in single pieces that appear as three individual shingles and are thinner making them less durable. Architectural shingles have an additional layer of asphalt on them, helping to provide a 3D effect and increasing their lifespan.

Asphalt shingles of any kind are a fantastic option if installed properly. They come in a variety of colors and are supported by underlayment protections for a durable, cost effective and rejuvenated total roofing system.

One crucial aspect of installing asphalt shingles is that the nailing, which fastens the shingles, is done appropriately. Nails are installed in the shingle nailing region, which is where the shingle is widest. Each row of shingles overlaps the row below it, helping to stop wind-driven rain from penetrating under the shingles and through nailing holes.

TopLine Home Improvement offers free, no-obligation quotes on roofing with an always honest and thorough inspection. Our clean and seamless install process will give you the strong and beautiful new roof you’ve always wanted without any worry. Contact us today for a free estimate and let us work with you to ensure the best roofing solution for your home.

See the Difference Quality Craftsmanship Makes

Home Transformations

Customer Testimonials

See What Homeowners Have to Say About Partnering With TopLine Home Improvement

Working with TopLine was a great experience. They made me and my mom feel valued as customers. Their prices were competitive and their work impeccable.

Karen W.

Great service, high quality product and good price. We were replacing windows in two rental apartments, TopLine was recommended by a neighbor and I could not be happier with the final result.

Justyna K.

We couldn’t be happier with the finished product. The team was courteous and respectful. Did a great cleanup when the job was complete. We would recommend TopLine to anyone looking to give their home an upgrade!

Patrick B.

Highly recommended! Excellent windows and craftsmanship at a reasonable price. Nick was professional, responsive, and easy to work with. We are very happy with our new windows.

Jack F.

Windows arrived when they were promised. The work was thorough and the workers were meticulous. I am delighted that my drafts are gone. Thank you TopLine!

Mary A.

To rate TopLine would take so many words. They get the job done and the guys who came to install my doors were fantastic and extremely professional. Words are not enough to rave about how everything went from start to completion.

A.C.

BBB A+ Logo
A+
Rating
Facebook Logo
5.0
Rating
Google Logo
4.9
Rating
Yelp Logo
4.5
Rating

Trusted by the best in the business!

OKNA logo
James Hardie Logo
Home Guard Doors & Windows logo
Provia
Alside Logo
Andersen Windows & Doors Logo
Owens Corning Logo
PlyGem Logo
Your Local Experts

Contact Us

Bright, sunny daytime view of the Topline Home Improvement brick building with blue signage advertising windows, doors, roofing, and siding.

Address
2056 Utica Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11234
Get Directions
Hours

Monday - Friday: 9:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM (evenings by appointment)
Sunday: Closed

Phone Number
(718) 769-4555
© 2026 TopLine Home Improvement. All Rights Reserved
Lead Safe Certified Form Badge

NYC HIC #834535
NJ HIC #13VH13206300